Virginia Custody: The Perils of Trial Illustrated

I usually don’t think much about custody decisions by our Virginia Court of Appeals.  The appellants almost always lose.  They usually lose because trial courts rarely commit a legal error like failing to consider the relevant custody factors under Va. Code Sec. 20-124.3.  And they usually lose because the trial courts rarely abuse their discretion, which is a standard that our appellate courts have interpreted as “was the judge drunk?”  So I rarely understand why custody appellants waste their money on an almost surefire loss.  Yet, there’s a recent appellate custody decision that made me think “I get it.”  I get why the appellant couldn’t help but call out the trial court for its questionable decision despite knowing it’d be a sure loss. Continue reading